Surface treatment and tribology
Cutting tools are coated with hard films such as TiN. Which is an appropriate way to choose the coating method for cemented carbide tools and for high-speed tool steel (HSS) tools?
- AHSS gains secondary hardening on tempering and so resists heat better than cemented carbide, so even thick coating by thermal CVD at about 1000 °C does not lower its hardness
- BThermal CVD at about 1000 °C suits cemented carbide, but HSS is coated by PVD at about 500 °C or below so as not to exceed its tempering temperature (about 550 °C)
- CPVD only evaporates the source physically and uses no chemical reaction, so it cannot make compound films such as TiN and can only deposit metal films
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B. Thermal CVD at about 1000 °C suits cemented carbide, but HSS is coated by PVD at about 500 °C or below so as not to exceed its tempering temperature (about 550 °C)
Thermal CVD forms films by reacting source gases such as TiCl₄, N₂ and H₂ at about 1000 °C. It gives thick, well-adhering films and is widely used for cemented carbide tools, which do not soften at high temperature. HSS gets its hardness from quenching and tempering, so heating above the tempering temperature softens it, and requenching also raises problems of dimensional change. PVD methods such as sputtering and arc ion plating are therefore used at about 500 °C or below. Even with PVD, compound films such as TiN, TiAlN and CrN can be made by reactive deposition, in which Ti is evaporated or sputtered in a nitrogen-containing atmosphere. The secondary hardening of HSS occurs in the tempering range; its heat resistance is lower than that of cemented carbide, and it cannot withstand thermal CVD temperatures.